IBC

1.1 PHI Kaz Matsui
1.2 CIN Ryan Wagner
1.3 BOS Maels Rodriguez
1.4 KC Delmon Young
1.5 KC Rickie Weeks
1.6 NYY Jeffery Allison
1.7 MIL Chad Cordero
1.8 ARI Kyle Sleeth
1.9 TEX Tim Stauffer
1.10 CWS Paul Maholm
1.11 SD Aaron Hill
1.12 PIT John Danks
1.13 CHC Michael Aubrey
1.14 MON Chad Billingsley
1.15 STL Nick Markakis
1.16 DET Chris Lubanski
1.17 BOS Lou Palmisano
1.18 COL Shingo Takatsu
1.19 ANA Ian Stewart
1.20 PHI Ryan Harvey
1.21 TB Brad Sullivan
1.22 OAK Brian Anderson
1.23 HOU Conar Jackson
1.24 SEA John Banks
1.25 CIN David Aardama
1.26 NYM Xavier Paul
1.27 SF Akinori Otsuka
1.28 HOU Roger Whitaker
1.29 FLA Eric Duncan
1.30 MIN Ryan Sweeney

2.1 TEX Shawn Marcum
2.2 LA Jamie Vermilyea
2.3 BAL Vince Sinisi
2.4 TOR Andy Laroche
2.5 MIN Brandon Wood
2.6 STL Tony Gwynn Jr
2.7 MIL Adam Miller
2.8 ARI Lastings Milledge
2.9 TEX David Murphy
2.10 CWS Daric Barton
2.11 SD Matt Moses
2.12 PIT Omar Quintanilla
2.13 CHC Tony Giarratano
2.14 MON Thomas Gorzelanny
2.15 STL Adam Jones
2.16 DET John Sborz
2.17 CLE Luis Atilano
2.18 COL Matt Murton
2.19 ANA Joe Reyes
2.20 PHI James Houser
2.21 TB Jamie D'Antona
2.22 OAK Jason Hirsh
2.23 SF Brian Finch
2.24 SEA Sean Marshall
2.25 KC Robert Valido
2.26 NYM Carlos Quentin
2.27 SF Abe Alvarez
2.28 HOU Wes Littleton
2.29 TEX Aaron Marsden
2.30 KC Mitch Maier

3.1 CIN Jonathan Barrat
3.2 ATL Bob Zimmerman
3.3 SEA Andre Ethier
3.4 BOS Jimmy Barthmaier
3.5 MIN Shane Costa
3.6 ATL Estee Harris
3.7 MIL Brad Snyder
3.8 ARI Ryan Feierabend
3.9 FLA Richard Nanita
3.10 BOS Chris Ray
3.11 SD Vito Chiarava
3.12 PIT Scott Baker
3.13 CHC Paul Bacot
3.15 STL Danny Core
3.17 CLE Logan Kensing
3.18 COL Aaron Laffey
3.19 ANA Nate Schierholtz
3.20 FLA Jon Nickerson
3.21 TB Kurt Isenberg
3.22 OAK John Hudgins
3.23 FLA Tom Mastny
3.24 SEA Chris Schutt
3.25 CIN Jeremy Cleveland
3.26 NYM Errol Simonitsch
3.27 SF Sergio Silva
3.28 SF David Marchbanks
3.29 BOS Michael Bourn
3.30 KC Adam Bass

4.1 HOU Ryan Roberts
4.2 TEX Matt Lorenzo
4.3 BAL Brian Snyder
4.4 TEX Justin Saltalamacchia
4.5 MIN Tom Pauly
4.6 LAD Ryan Klatt
4.7 MIL Scott Beerer
4.8 ARI Josh Whitesell
4.9 TEX Lee Mitchell
4.10 CWS Clinton King
4.11 SD Tyler Clippard
4.12 PIT Beau Vaughn
4.13 CHC Josh Anderson
4.15 LAD Jai Miller
4.17 CLE William Vaughn
4.19 ANA Jerry Owens
4.20 PHI Jake Stevens
4.21 TB Yobal Dunas
4.22 OAK Ryan Garko
4.23 CWS Dennis Dove
4.25 FLA Eric Rodland
4.26 NYM Brian Marshall
4.27 NYY Javon Moran
4.28 HOU Craig Stansberry
4.29 BOS Shane Hawk

5.1 SF Pat Misch
5.2 PHI Steven Doetsch
5.4 TOR Antoin Gray
5.6 LAD Peter Stonard
5.7 MIL Matt Chico
5.8 ARI Javier Herrera
5.10 CWS Chris Goodman
5.11 SD Joe Wilson
5.13 CHC Brian Bannister
5.14 MON Corey Coles
5.15 STL Stuart Pomeranz
5.19 ANA Kyle Pearson
5.20 PHI Todd Jennings
5.21 TB Brendan Ryan
5.23 NYY Chuck Tiffany

ANA - Dave Nash
1.19 Ian Stewart
2.19 Joe Reyes
3.19 Nate Schierholtz
4.19 Jerry Owens
5.19 Kyle Pearson

ARI - James Whittemore
1.8 Kyle Sleeth
2.8 Lastings Milledge
3.8 Ryan Feierabend
4.8 Josh Whitesell
5.8 Javier Herrera

ATL - Richard Bishop
3.2 Bob Zimmerman
3.6 Estee Harris

BAL - Joe Kraut
2.3 Vince Sinisi
4.3 Brian Snyder

BOS - Bren Dillon
1.3 Maels "Fucking" Rodriguez
1.17 Lou Palmisano
3.10 Chris Ray
3.29 Michael Bourn
3.4 Jimmy Barthmaier
4.29 Shane Hawk

CHC - Gabe Hammad
1.13 Michael Aubrey
2.13 Tony Giarratano
3.13 Paul Bacot
4.13 Josh Anderson
5.13 Brian Bannister

CIN - Nate Hunter
1.2 Ryan Wagner
1.25 David Aardama
3.1 Jonathan Barrat
3.25 Jeremy Cleveland

CLE - Keith Belix
2.17 Luis Atilano
3.17 Logan Kensing
4.17 William Vaughn

COL - Justin/Dan/Brendan/Lenny
1.18 Shingo Takatsu
2.18 Matt Murton
3.18 Aaron Laffey

CWS - Brett Degen
1.10 Paul Maholm
2.10 Daric Barton
4.10 Clinton King
4.23 Dennis Dove
5.10 Chris Goodman

DET - Sean Stoner
1.16 Chris Lubanski
2.16 John Sborz

FLA - Rick Ottavino
1.29 Eric Duncan
3.20 Jon Nickerson
3.23 Tom Mastny
3.9 Richard Nanita
4.25 Eric Rodland

HOU - Pat Gillespie
1.23 Conor Jackson
1.28 Roger Whitaker
2.28 Wes Littleton
4.1 Ryan Roberts
4.28 Craig Stansberry

KC - Josh Morgan
1.4 Delmon Young
1.5 Rickie Weeks
2.25 Robert Valido
2.30 Mitch Maier
3.30 Adam Bass

LAD - Shawn Walsh
2.2 Jamie Vermilyea
4.15 Jai Miller
4.6 Ryan Klatt
5.6 Peter Stonard

MIL - Dan Vacek
1.7 Chad Cordero
2.7 Adam Miller
3.7 Brad Snyder
4.7 Scott Beerer
5.7 Matt Chico

MIN - Andrew Howard
1.30 Ryan Sweeney
2.5 Brandon Wood
3.5 Shane Costa
4.5 Tom Pauly

MON - Tyler Fyock
1.14 Chad Billingsley
2.14 Thomas Gorzelanny
5.14 Corey Coles

NYM - JP Starkey
1.26 Xavier Paul
2.26 Carlos Quentin
3.26 Errol Simonitsch
4.26 Brian Marshall

NYY - Jason Bornas
1.6 Jeffery Allison
4.27 Javon Moran
5.23 Chuck Tiffany

OAK - Nick Perry
1.22 Brian Anderson
2.22 Jason Hirsh
3.22 John Hudgins
4.22 Ryan Garko

PHI - Chris Jericho
1.1 Kaz Matsui
1.20 Ryan Harvey
2.20 James Houser
4.20 Jake Stevens
5.2 Steven Doetsch
5.20 Todd Jennigs

PIT - Roy/Aaron L/Andy
1.12 John Danks
2.12 Omar Quintanilla
3.12 Scott Baker
4.12 Beau Vaughn

SD - Brad Geiss
1.11 Aaron Hill
2.11 Matt Moses
3.11 Vito Chiarava
4.11 Tyler Clippard
5.11 Joe Wilson

SEA - Brennan Church
1.24 John Banks
2.24 Sean Marshall
3.3 Andre Ethier
3.24 Chris Schutt

SF - Nils Erickson
1.27 Akinori Otsuka
2.23 Brian Finch
2.27 Abe Alvarez
3.27 Sergio Silva
3.28 David Marchbanks
5.1 Pat Misch

STL - Aaron Dorman
1.15 Nick Markakis
2.6 Tony Gwynn Jr
2.15 Adam Jones
3.15 Danny Core
5.15 Stuart Pomeranz

TB - Pat Bishop
1.21 Brad Sullivan
2.21 Jamie D'Antona
3.21 Kurt Isenberg
4.21 Yobal Dunas
5.21 Brendan Ryan

TEX - Kegan LeFort
1.9 Tim Stauffer
2.1 Shawn Marcum
2.9 David Murphy
2.29 Aaron Marsden
4.2 Matt Lorenzo
4.4 Justin Saltalamacchia
4.9 Lee Mitchell

TOR - Brett Zalaski
2.4 Andy Laroche
5.4 Antoin Gray


Base Draft Order
1 Florida
2 Atlanta
3 Baltimore
4 Toronto
5 Minnesota
6 LA Dodgers
7 Milwaukee
8 Arizona
9 Texas
10 Chicago WS
11 San Diego
12 Pittsburgh
13 Chicago Cubs
14 Montreal
15 St Louis
16 Detroit
17 Cleveland
18 Colorado
19 Anaheim
20 Philadelphia
21 Tampa Bay
22 Oakland
23 NY Yankees
24 Seattle
25 Cincinnati
26 NY Mets
27 San Francisco
28 Houston
29 Boston
30 Kansas City

Best Overall Draft: St Louis
Second Best Overall Draft: Pittsburgh

Best Value Draft: Montreal

Worst Overall Draft: LA Dodgers

Best 1st Round Pick: 1.14 - Chad Billingsley

Worst 1st Round Pick: 1.3 - Maels Rodriguez

Best 2nd Round Pick: 2.26 - Carlos Quentin

Best 3rd Round Pick: 3.12 - Scott Baker

Best 4th Round Pick: 4.4 - Jarrod Saltalamacchia

Best 5th Round Pick: 5.13 - Brian Bannister

There's a typo in there... it's Maels "Fucking" Rodriguez.

RedSox wrote:There's a typo in there... it's Maels "Fucking" Rodriguez.

Got it

The one consolation on that pick is it seems like there were a lot of dogs int he first round of that draft. Wagner had a nice debut then bombed. Matsui has been largely a disappointment. Allison is an addict. Sleeth retired. Stauffer is terrible. Even Delmon has struggled to reach what everyone thinks he should be (or even to be league average).

I got Billingsley and Xavier Paul in the first round - did you hate me back then?

Royals wrote:I got Billingsley and Xavier Paul in the first round - did you hate me back then?

Z, we've always kinda hated you

2003 was my first draft, so those Milwaukee picks were all made by me.

Marlins wrote:2003 was my first draft, so those Milwaukee picks were all made by me.

Cool, thanks. It's hard to tell with some of the dates that teams changed hands.

Royals wrote:I got Billingsley and Xavier Paul in the first round - did you hate me back then?

JP took Xavier Paul?

Nope - I took both of them...that's when I actually liked 1st round picks...

I definitely selected Paul. Possible/Probable that I dealt him immediately afterward.

Funny you should say that, because I have this massive file of papers from all the IBC drafts that I've saved - and on every sheet for that year I'm selecting Paul. Paul was a 4th round pick that I took a huge shot on - and he's performed, well, more like a 4th round pick than a 1st. Maybe we had an agreement for you to trade me him immediately after the draft, but Paul was my guy...

Z, it says 1.26 right in the results...

Right - I'm not an idiot - I'm saying I had control of that pick when I made the selection - or, if I didn't, JP and I had a deal in place where he drafted Paul for me.

I made two massive reaches within about a dozen picks - LaRoche and Paul - one of them worked out well. I also picked Billingsley as well.