IBC

2002

Round 1 Pick 16: Cole Hamels
Round 2 Pick 16: Jason Pridie
Round 3 Pick 16: Aaron Coonrod
Round 4 Pick 16: Jake Blalock
Round 5 Pick 16: Brad Thompson

2003

Round 1 Pick 15: Nick Markakis
Round 2 Pick 6: Tony Gwynn Jr.
Round 2 Pick 15: Adam Jones
Round 3 Pick 15: Danny Core
Round 5 Pick 15: Stuart Pomeranz

2004

Round 1 Pick 22: Reid Brignac
Round 2 Pick 22: Adam Lind
Round 3 Pick 18: Garrett Mock
Round 3 Pick 22: Scott Lewis
Round 4 Pick 22: Danny Hill

2005

Round 1 Pick 20: Beau Jones
Round 1 Pick 27: Matt Garza
Round 2 Pick 27: Chase Headley
Round 3 Pick 27: Michael Brantley
Round 4 Pick 27: David Hernandez

2006

Round 1 Pick 17: Brett Anderson
Round 2 Pick 17: Manny Burriss
Round 3 Pick 17: Cory Rasmus
Round 4 Pick 17: Alex Cobb

2007

Round 1 Pick 30: Brett Cecil
Round 2 Pick 30: Jonathon LuCroy
Round 3 Pick 30: Drew Cumberland
Round 4 Pick 30: Freddie Freeman
Round 5 Pick 30: Deryk Hooker

2008

Round 2 Pick 14: Lonnie Chisenhall
Round 2 Pick 30: Jordan Lyles
Round 3 Pick 30: Jerome Hoes
Round 4 Pick 30: Kyle Russell

2009

Round 1 Pick 22: Matt Hobgood
Round 2 Pick 21: Marc Krauss
Round 3 Pick 10: Brooks Pounders
Round 3 Pick 21: Matt Adams
Round 4 Pick 21: James Needy

2010

Round 1 Pick 14: Josh Sale
Round 1 Pick 25: Luis Heredia
Round 2 Pick 1: Mike Foltynewicz
Round 2 Pick 14: Taijuan Walker
Round 3 Pick 6: Kellen Sweeney
Round 3 Pick 14: Ryan Brett
Round 4 Pick 14: Vincent Velazquez
Round 5 Pick 14: Chad Lewis

2011

Round 1 Pick 7: Bubba Starling
Round 1 Pick 14: Taylor Jungmann
Round 1 Pick 16: CJ Cron
Round 1 Pick 18: Taylor Guerrieri
Round 1 Pick 26: Blake Swihart
Round 3 Pick 19: Madison Boer

2012

Round 1 Pick 6: Kevin Gausman
Round 2 Pick 6: Victor Roache
Round 3 Pick 6: Mitch Brown
Round 3 Pick 20: Kevin Plawecki
Round 4 Pick 6: Chase DeJong

2013

Round 2 Pick 16: Corey Knebel
Round 3 Pick 6: Kean Wong
Round 3 Pick 22: Jeff Thompson
Round 3 Pick 24: Dustin Peterson
Round 4 Pick 7: Daniel Palka

2014

Round 1 Pick 6: Yasmany Tomas
Round 2 Pick 6: Michael Chavis
Round 2 Pick 16: Luke Weaver
Round 3 Pick 6: Carson Sands
Round 5 Pick 6: Tripp Martin
Round 6 Pick 2: Tyler Bray

2015

Round 1 Pick 17: Austin Riley
Round 2 Pick 6: Beau Burrows
Round 3 Pick 3: Drew Finley
Round 3 Pick 17: Jake Woodford
Round 3 Pick 20: Lucas Herbert
Round 5 Pick 17: Dylan Thompson

2016

Round 2 Pick 12: Kyle Muller
Round 2 Pick 28: Cole Stobbe
Round 3 Pick 18: Will Smith
Round 3 Pick 27: Bryse Wilson
Round 4 Pick 27: Walker Robbins

2017

Round 1 Pick 21: Drew Ellis
Round 2 Pick 21: Corbin Martin
Round 3 Pick 21: Caden Lemons
Round 4 Pick 15: Chad Spanberger
Round 5 Pick 21: Buddy Kennedy
Round 5 Pick 22: Kade McClure

Looks like your drafting skills have dropped off of late...

Good idea

Dodgers wrote:Looks like your drafting skills have dropped off of late...

I don't know. I'd take two probably top 50 prospects from any draft with a normal allotment of picks, especially picking 30th. And he has pretty consistently gotten exactly one huge stud, Hamels, Markakis, Brignac, Garza and Anderson in those five drafts, with Headley and Adam Jones a couple of years and three decent role players in 04.

The only things I wish I'd changed were not cutting Adam Jones and Scott Lewis. I wanted a SS of the future and that's what Jones played in high school, but when he got moved to CF I stupidly cut him because I had a major clue for Tony Giarratano, who I think would be a starting SS right now had his career not been derailed by injuries. I never thought Scott Lewis would overcome the injury bug because he was hurt a ton in college and barely pitched his first couple years in the minors

Cardinals wrote:The only things I wish I'd changed were not cutting Adam Jones and Scott Lewis.

Lewis and Jones are two of my dumbest cuts as well, but even dumber b/c I picked up both of those guys after you dropped them, hung onto them each for a while, then dropped them right before they busted out (to diff. degrees) and shot up in value. Good thing Joel Guzman and his tools enjoyed one of my roster spots for like 4 years but I couldn't find a way to stick with Jones. Can't win 'em all I guess (or any sometimes).

Cardinals wrote:The only things I wish I'd changed were not cutting Adam Jones and Scott Lewis. I wanted a SS of the future and that's what Jones played in high school, but when he got moved to CF I stupidly cut him because I had a major clue for Tony Giarratano, who I think would be a starting SS right now had his career not been derailed by injuries. I never thought Scott Lewis would overcome the injury bug because he was hurt a ton in college and barely pitched his first couple years in the minors

I can add cutting Alex Cobb to pick up Freddy Guzman to be a pinch runner for September 2009 to my list of stupidity

Cardinals wrote:2002

Round 1 Pick 16: Cole Hamels
Round 2 Pick 16: Jason Pridie
Round 3 Pick 16: Aaron Coonrod
Round 4 Pick 16: Jake Blalock
Round 5 Pick 16: Brad Thompson

2003

Round 1 Pick 15: Nick Markakis
Round 2 Pick 6: Tony Gwynn Jr.
Round 2 Pick 15: Adam Jones
Round 3 Pick 15: Danny Core
Round 5 Pick 15: Stuart Pomeranz

2004

Round 1 Pick 22: Reid Brignac
Round 2 Pick 22: Adam Lind
Round 3 Pick 18: Garrett Mock
Round 3 Pick 22: Scott Lewis
Round 4 Pick 22: Danny Hill

2005

Round 1 Pick 20: Beau Jones
Round 1 Pick 27: Matt Garza
Round 2 Pick 27: Chase Headley
Round 3 Pick 27: Michael Brantley
Round 4 Pick 27: David Hernandez

2006

Round 1 Pick 17: Brett Anderson
Round 2 Pick 17: Manny Burriss
Round 3 Pick 17: Cory Rasmus
Round 4 Pick 17: Alex Cobb

2007

Round 1 Pick 30: Brett Cecil
Round 2 Pick 30: Jonathon LuCroy
Round 3 Pick 30: Drew Cumberland
Round 4 Pick 30: Freddie Freeman
Round 5 Pick 30: Deryk Hooker

2008

Round 2 Pick 14: Lonnie Chisenhall
Round 2 Pick 30: Jordan Lyles
Round 3 Pick 30: Jerome Hoes
Round 4 Pick 30: Kyle Russell

2009

Round 1 Pick 22: Matt Hobgood
Round 2 Pick 21: Marc Krauss
Round 3 Pick 10: Brooks Pounders
Round 3 Pick 21: Matt Adams
Round 4 Pick 21: James Needy

2010

Round 1 Pick 14: Josh Sale
Round 1 Pick 25: Luis Heredia
Round 2 Pick 1: Mike Foltynewicz
Round 2 Pick 14: Taijuan Walker
Round 3 Pick 6: Kellen Sweeney
Round 3 Pick 14: Ryan Brett
Round 4 Pick 14: Vincent Velazquez
Round 5 Pick 14: Chad Lewis

2011

Round 1 Pick 7: Bubba Starling
Round 1 Pick 14: Taylor Jungmann
Round 1 Pick 16: CJ Cron
Round 1 Pick 18: Taylor Guerrieri
Round 1 Pick 26: Blake Swihart
Round 3 Pick 19: Madison Boer

2012

Round 1 Pick 6: Kevin Gausman
Round 2 Pick 6: Victor Roache
Round 3 Pick 6: Mitch Brown
Round 3 Pick 20: Kevin Plawecki
Round 4 Pick 6: Chase DeJong

2013

Round 2 Pick 16: Corey Knebel
Round 3 Pick 6: Kean Wong
Round 3 Pick 22: Jeff Thompson
Round 3 Pick 24: Dustin Peterson
Round 4 Pick 7: Daniel Palka

2014

Round 1 Pick 6: Yasmany Tomas
Round 2 Pick 6: Michael Chavis
Round 2 Pick 16: Luke Weaver
Round 3 Pick 6: Carson Sands
Round 5 Pick 6: Tripp Martin
Round 6 Pick 2: Tyler Bray

2015

Round 1 Pick 17: Austin Riley
Round 2 Pick 6: Beau Burrows
Round 3 Pick 3: Drew Finley
Round 3 Pick 17: Jake Woodford
Round 3 Pick 20: Lucas Herbert
Round 5 Pick 17: Dylan Thompson

2016

Round 2 Pick 12: Kyle Muller
Round 2 Pick 28: Cole Stobbe
Round 3 Pick 18: Will Smith
Round 3 Pick 27: Bryse Wilson
Round 4 Pick 27: Walker Robbins

My complete draft history.

Best Pick: Freddie Freeman with the last pick of the 4th round in 2007. Struggled in the GCL after getting drafted in the 2nd, that's the only way I can figure that he fell that far.

Worst Pick: How about the entire 2011 draft? Geez, miss on 5 first rounders from blowing up my team in a very deep draft. Talked myself out of George Springer (cause I had Bubba why take another OF) and Jose Fernandez (every report I read said he'd end up in the pen).

Most Frustrating: 2010 even though I hit on Walker and Velazquez. I was going to take Matt Harvey and was deciding between him and Sale. Talked it over with JP and talked myself into Sale since he was supposed to be the best HS bat in the draft and Harvey had injury red flags. All he did was throw change at strippers in Bowling Green and get suspended for drugs. Took Luis Heredia late in the first because I'd completely forgotten about Carlos Martinez. I could've drafted almost an entire damn rotation that draft and had Carlos/Harvey/Walker/Velazquez