IBC

To point #2.

You and John A.

Both players have been marketed heavily over the past 4-5 months. If either of you had made any reasonable offer you might have acquired one or both players. Since neither of you did, I have no clue what either of you is bitching about.

I mean seriously, I've seen some real doosers already go flying through this offseason.........and you both choose to bitch about this deal?

I mean really, Seriously?

the best part is how he called it beyond ridiculous... i thought that was pretty funny.

My two cents - fair deal.

Young would seem to be what is sparking the concerns, but he has already peaked (and now declining) on OFF and is below average on DEF as a SS.

Dejesus has another year or two to maintain his peak that he probably reached in 2008.

Madson for Mijares and McAllister is fair.

Just my opinion.

Kelly CLE

Yea nick its funny to you cause you took him town on the deal.