According to his manager,
Troy Melton will be a starter.
Melton will not have to handle another move next year. And as the Tigers revisit questions about their rotation for next season, Melton — who totaled 129 1/3 innings in the Minors, regular season and playoffs — is a potentially big part.
“He’s a starter,” Hinch said.
https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/mining-the-news-10-29-25/
Of all the moves the Tigers made leading up to the Trade Deadline three months ago, one of the most impactful involved a player already on the roster.
Scott Harris didn’t have to give up anything to get reliever
Troy Melton -- except starter Troy Melton. The shift in role, made after just two starts for Detroit, shaped how Harris attacked the Deadline, from the starters he added -- Chris Paddack was acquired the day of Melton’s second start, with Charlie Morton coming a few days later -- to the relievers he added (Kyle Finnegan, Rafael Montero, Paul Sewald, Codi Heuer) and didn’t add.
“We realized that one of our better relievers might be Troy Melton,” Harris, the Tigers’ president of baseball operations, said at the time. “We should give him a chance to be there.”
In providing that chance, the Tigers opted for Melton over potential trades that likely would’ve required giving up Melton, who rose through the Tigers’ farm system and became a popular name in trade talks.
“It was a big need for us to add more swing-and-miss to our 'pen,” Harris said last week. “And we had a young player with high-octane stuff that could pitch in a multi-inning role, get some really big outs for us and [bring] a new dynamic to [manager A.J. Hinch’s] 'pen, so that when he looked down on the card, he had multiple paths to get to the finish line.”
How did it turn out? There were times that the Tigers badly missed Melton as a starter, a loss exacerbated by the struggles of Paddack and Morton. The lack of rotation depth played a role in Detroit’s late-season collapse, and it was notable that the Tigers called on Melton for a spot start in Cleveland in the final week of the regular season to help shore up a postseason spot.
While Melton posted a 2.14 ERA over the final two months, allowing just 19 hits over 33 2/3 innings, he wasn’t quite as much of a swing-and-miss pitcher in relief as he was as a starter. But come the postseason, Melton’s versatility was a big reason the Tigers came as close to an ALCS berth as they did.
After giving up four runs in his lone appearance in the AL Wild Card Series against the Guardians, taking the loss in Game 2, Melton pitched in three of five games against the Mariners in the Division Series. His four-inning start helped the Tigers take the series opener in Seattle. His three scoreless innings of relief in Game 4 bridged the gap from Finnegan to closer Will Vest and earned Melton the win that helped force Game 5, where he pitched a scoreless 10th inning.
Melton delivered eight innings of one-run ball against Seattle with three walks and eight strikeouts. Only Finnegan pitched in more games in the series, and only Tarik Skubal pitched more innings.
As Harris tackled questions about their Trade Deadline strategy last week at the Tigers’ end-of-season media session, Melton was a move he felt good about.
“He got really big outs for us,” Harris said last week, “and he handled the transition from the rotation to the 'pen as seamlessly as any young player we have seen since I’ve been here.”
Take Finnegan out of the equation, and Melton delivered more postseason appearances and innings than the rest of the Tigers’ trade acquisitions combined. He also, Harris strongly hinted, outpitched some of the pitchers the Tigers could have traded Melton to get.
“I would tell you that the players that were most closely connected to us via the media would have cost either a player on our postseason roster, plus additional pieces, or one of our top prospects plus additional pieces,” Harris said. “In some cases, with those deals that were most closely connected to us, those players -- some of them -- didn’t perform at all down the stretch, would’ve been a free agent in two months and would have cost a player on our postseason roster that actually performed better than the player we [would have] acquired ...
“I don’t regret those deals at all. I actually am proud of our group for evaluating the players we had well and thinking, ‘Hey, these players are going to help us this year and in the future, and get some really big outs for us in the postseason.”
Melton will not have to handle another move next year. And as the Tigers revisit questions about their rotation for next season, Melton -- who totaled 129 1/3 innings in the Minors, regular season and playoffs -- is a potentially big part.
“He’s a starter,” Hinch said.
https://www.mlb.com/news/troy-melton-ex ... s-rotation