2005 IBC Draft Review

Rangers · Post by **Rangers** » Tue Dec 30, 2008 12:06 am

1.1 NYY Justin Upton
1.2 LAD Ryan Zimmerman
1.3 SD Alex Gordon
1.4 SD Craig Hansen
1.5 ARI Cameron Maybin
1.6 DET Troy Tulowitzki
1.7 MIN Jeff Clement
1.8 PIT Mark Pawelek
1.9 ATL Mike Pelfrey
1.10 NYY Ricky Romero
1.11 DET Andrew McCutchen
1.12 CIN Chris Volstad
1.13 SEA Cesar Carillo
1.14 COL Jay Bruce
1.15 WAS Ryan Braun
1.16 DET Brandon Snyder
1.17 MIL Kenji Jojima
1.18 DET Travis Wood
1.19 ATL Colby Rasmus
1.20 STL Beau Jones
1.21 CIN Cliff Pennington
1.22 ARI Nolan Reimold
1.23 CIN Aaron Thompson
1.24 TOR Yunel Escobar
1.25 WAS Matt Torra
1.26 CLE Jacoby Ellsbury
1.27 STL Matt Garza
1.29 WAS Jed Lowrie
1.30 NYY C.J Henry
1.31 NYM Mark McCormick
1.32 CLE Taylor Teagarden

2.1 WAS Joey Devine
2.2 LAD Travis Buck
2.3 WAS Lance Broadway
2.4 SD Garrett Olson (LHP)
2.5 ARI Luke Hochevar
2.6 OAK John Mayberry
2.7 MIN Kevin Slowey
2.8 PIT J. Brent Cox
2.9 ATL Clay Buchholz
2.10 ARI Craig Italiano
2.11 CWS Matt Green
2.12 BOS Will Inman
2.13 SEA Donald Veal
2.14 COL Sean West
2.15 NYM Jeff Bianchi
2.16 DET Thomas Mendoza
2.17 MIL Michael Bowden
2.18 BAL Micah Owings
2.19 CLE Jared Lansford
2.20 ATL Mike Costanzo
2.21 CIN Trevor Crowe
2.22 ARI Brandon Erbe
2.23 PHI Mark Romanczuk
2.24 TOR Eli Iorg
2.25 NYY Brian Bogusevic
2.26 KC Chris Nicoll
2.27 STL Chase Headley
2.28 DET Kevin Whelan
2.29 ATL Sean O'Sullivan
2.30 TEX Jonathan Egan
2.31 CLE John Drennen

3.1 HOU Chris Mason
3.2 LAD Gaby Sanchez
3.3 BOS Ryan Tucker
3.4 SD Bryan Morris
3.5 TEX Michael Durant
3.6 OAK Ryan Mount
3.7 MIN Stephen Head
3.8 PIT Jeff Larish
3.9 ATL Kyle Winters
3.10 ARI Johnny Whittleman
3.11 KC Brett Gardner
3.12 SF Wade Townsend
3.13 SEA Dan Griffin
3.14 COL Austin Jackson
3.16 PHI Nick Stavinoha
3.17 MIL Yahmed Yema
3.18 BAL Tyler Greene
3.19 CHC Paul Kelly
3.20 SF Shinji Mori
3.21 NYY Aaron Cunningham
3.22 ARI Chaz Roe
3.23 BOS Jacob Marceaux
3.24 TOR Nick Hundley
3.25 BOS Josh Flores
3.26 CLE Jimmy Shull
3.27 STL Michael Brantley
3.28 SF Nick Webber
3.29 SF Tyler Herron
3.30 KC Ryan Patterson
3.31 CLE Drew Thompson

4.1 CLE Ryan Mullins
4.2 LAD Adam Rosales
4.3 BOS Omar Aguilar
4.4 SD Mitch Boggs
4.5 KC Brent Fisher
4.7 MIN Brian Duensing
4.8 PIT Koby Clemens
4.9 HOU Sam LeCure
4.10 ARI Trevor Bell
4.11 CWS Matt Gamel
4.12 CIN Josh Bell (3B)
4.13 SEA Bryan Anderson
4.14 COL Jeremy Hellickson
4.17 MIL Nick Weglarz
4.18 BAL Kris Harvey
4.19 CHC Tyler Bullock
4.20 ATL P.J. Phillips
4.22 ARI Jeff Lyman
4.24 TOR Yusaku Iriki
4.26 CLE John Matulia
4.27 STL David Hernandez
4.28 SF Ivan De Jesus
4.29 HOU Mike Billek
4.30 NYY Henry Sanchez

5.1 DET Justin Maxwell
5.3 BOS Aaron Cunningham
5.5 TEX Matthew Avery
5.8 PIT Wilfredo Pujols
5.9 ANA Jensen Lewis
5.13 SEA Jason Ray
5.14 COL Michael Kirkman
5.17 MIL Justin Sellers
5.18 BAL Cesar Ramos
5.20 ANA Blake Owen
5.21 CIN Anderson Gomes
5.22 ARI Jon Niese
5.24 TOR Steve Hammond
5.25 BAL Ben Copeland
5.29 HOU Brad Corley

6.1 DET Vince Mazzaro
6.3 BOS Jason Neighborgall
6.22 ARI? Anthony Varvaro
7.1 DET Chris Getz
7.22 ARI Daryl Jones
8.1 DET Josh Wall

Rangers · Post by **Rangers** » Tue Dec 30, 2008 12:11 am

ANA - JP Starkey
5.9 Jensen Lewis
5.20 Blake Owen

ARI - Jagger Traylor
1.5 Cameron Maybin
1.22 Nolan Reimold
2.5 (Luke Hochevar)
2.10 Craig Italiano
2.22 Brandon Erbe
3.10 Johnny Whittleman
3.22 Chaz Roe
4.10 Trevor Bell
4.22 Jeff Lyman
5.22 Jon Niese
6.22 Daryl Jones
7.22 Anthony Varvaro

ATL - Bobby Tierney
1.9 Mike Pelfrey
1.19 Colby Rasmus
2.9 Clay Buchholz
2.20 Mike Costanzo
2.29 Sean O'Sullivan
3.9 Kyle Winters
4.20 P.J. Phillips

BAL - Dan Vacek
2.18 Micah Owings
3.18 Tyler Greene
4.18 Kris Harvey
5.18 Cesar Ramos
5.25 Ben Copeland

BOS - Bren Dillon
2.12 Will Inman
3.3 Ryan Tucker
3.23 Jacob Marceaux
3.25 Josh Flores
4.3 Omar Aguilar
5.3 Aaron Cunningham
6.3 Jason Neighborgall

CHC - Richard Bishop
3.19 Paul Kelly
4.19 Tyler Bullock

CIN - Nate Hunter
1.12 Chris Volstad
1.21 Cliff Pennington
1.23 Aaron Thompson
2.21 Trevor Crowe
4.12 Josh Bell (3B)
5.21 Anderson Gomes

CLE - Keith Belix
1.26 Jacoby Ellsbury
1.32 Taylor Teagarden
2.19 Jared Lansford
2.31 John Drennen
3.26 Jimmy Shull
3.31 Drew Thompson
4.1 Ryan Mullins
4.26 John Matulia

COL - Jeff Brien
1.14 Jay Bruce
2.14 Sean West
3.14 Austin Jackson
4.14 Jeremy Hellickson
5.14 Michael Kirkman

CWS - Brett Degen
2.11 Matt Green
4.11 Matt Gamel

DET - Brett Perryman
1.6 Troy Tulowitzki
1.11 Andrew McCutchen
1.16 Brandon Snyder
1.18 Travis Wood
2.16 Thomas Mendoza
2.28 Kevin Whelan
5.1 Justin Maxwell
6.1 Vince Mazzaro
7.1 Chris Getz
8.1 Josh Wall

HOU - Ken Reese
3.1 Chris Mason
4.9 Sam LeCure
4.29 Mike Billek
5.29 Brad Corley

KC - Brett Zalaski
2.26 Chris Nicoll
3.11 Brett Gardner
3.30 Ryan Patterson
4.5 Brent Fisher

LAD - Shawn Walsh
1.2 Ryan Zimmerman
2.2 Travis Buck
3.2 Gaby Sanchez
4.2 Adam Rosales

MIL - Rob McQuown
1.17 Kenji Johjima
2.17 Michael Bowden
3.17 Yahmed Yema
4.17 Nick Weglarz
5.17 Justin Sellers

MIN - Andrew Howard
1.7 Jeff Clement
2.7 Kevin Slowey
3.7 Stephen Head
4.7 Brian Duensing

NYM - Kegan LeFort
1.31 Mark McCormick
2.15 Jeff Bianchi

NYY - Jason Bornas
1.1 Justin Upton
1.10 Ricky Romero
1.30 C.J Henry
2.25 Brian Bogusevic
3.21 (Aaron Cunningham)
4.30 Henry Sanchez

OAK - Jake Hamlin
2.6 John Mayberry
3.6 Ryan Mount

PHI - Nick Perry
2.23 Mark Romanczuk
3.16 Nick Stavinoha

PIT - Matt LeRoy
1.8 Mark Pawelek
2.8 J. Brent Cox
3.8 Jeff Larish
4.8 Koby Clemens
5.8 Wilfredo Pujols

SD - Martin Berryman
1.3 Alex Gordon
1.4 Craig Hansen
2.4 Garrett Olson (LHP)
3.4 Bryan Morris
4.4 Mitch Boggs

SEA - Brennan Church
1.13 Cesar Carillo
2.13 Donald Veal
3.13 Dan Griffin
4.13 Bryan Anderson
5.13 Jason Ray

SF - Nils Erickson
3.12 Wade Townsend
3.20 Shinji Mori
3.28 Nick Webber
3.29 Tyler Herron
4.28 Ivan De Jesus

STL - Aaron Dorman
1.20 Beau Jones
1.27 Matt Garza
2.27 Chase Headley
3.27 Michael Brantley
4.27 David Hernandez

TEX - ?
2.30 Jonathan Egan
3.5 Michael Durant
5.5 Matthew Avery

TOR - Pat Bishop
1.24 Yunel Escobar
2.24 Eli Iorg
3.24 Nick Hundley
4.24 Yusaku Iriki
5.24 Steve Hammond

WAS - Paul Sieczkowski
1.15 Ryan Braun
1.25 Matt Torra
1.29 Jed Lowrie
2.1 Joey Devine
2.3 Lance Broadway

Base Draft Order
(any help filling in blanks would be appreciated)
1 Detroit
2 LA Dodgers
3 Boston
4 San Diego
5 Texas
6 Oakland
7 Minnesota
8 Pittsburgh
9 Atlanta
10
11 Chicago WS
12
13 Seattle
14 Colorado
15
16
17 Milwaukee
18 Baltimore
19 Chicago Cubs
20 Anaheim
21 Cincinnati
22 Arizona
23
24 Toronto
25
26 Cleveland
27 St Louis
28 San Francisco
29 Houston
30 NY Yankees

Kansas City
Washington
NY Mets
Philadelphia
Tampa Bay
Florida

Rangers · Post by **Rangers** » Tue Dec 30, 2008 12:16 am

Best Overall Draft: Atlanta
Second Best Overall Draft: Colorado

Bobby! Who knew he had it in him? Pelfrey, Rasmus, Buchholz in one draft, not too bad. Colorado may wind up hitting on all of his first four picks, with a potential superstar leading the way.

Best Value Draft: Colorado

Worst Overall Draft: Texas

Best 1st Round Pick: 1.14 - Jay Bruce / 1.15 - Ryan Braun / 1.27 - Matt Garza
Lots of candidates of course, these seem like the best value at the moment.

Worst 1st Round Pick: 1.8 - Mark Pawelek / 1.18 - Travis Wood

Best 2nd Round Pick: 2.9 - Clay Buchholz

Slowey is a good choice as well and may still prove to be better in the long run.

Best 3rd Round Pick: 3.14 - Austin Jackson

Best 4th Round Pick: 4.14 - Jeremy Hellickson

Matt Gamel, Bryan Anderson also look interesting.

Best 5th Round Pick: 5.22 - Jon Niese

Yankees · Post by **Yankees** » Tue Dec 30, 2008 12:18 am

I drafted Nicoll and Gardner...with Patterson and Fisher...

Rangers · Post by **Rangers** » Tue Dec 30, 2008 12:29 am

Royals wrote:I drafted Nicoll and Gardner...with Patterson and Fisher...

I was thinking you picked Nicoll. Any idea why the old board had those wrong?

Giants · Post by **Giants** » Tue Dec 30, 2008 3:08 am

Haha I didn't quite understand the draft at this point (as evidenced by me trading pick #6 for Jeremy Accardo, oops).

Phillies · Post by **Phillies** » Tue Dec 30, 2008 12:58 pm

sadly, that was me in philly. didnt care that much obviously...